多伦多应该开征外国人买房附加税吗？

大家都应去省长，总理网站去呼吁。 开征外国人买房附加税， 空置税是必然的。不能再等了。

美国现在做IT的人很多放弃硅谷，涌入德州Austin等地，最重要的原因就是低房价。Tory前端时间去硅谷揽才，不知道他有没有成功招聘回来一个人。多伦多要维持竞争力，那肯定不是和纽约和硅谷比房价高，有良知的政客们应该想尽办法来维持一个安全的低生活费用的多伦多，这样才能让多伦多各行各业保持活力，而不是目前的房地产相关行业一枝独秀。

Of course. Politicians have to do something, otherwise why we even pay them?

加拿大三级政府的不作为才使本国普通百姓买不起房，估计年轻一代的加拿大人和有点本事之人很快就会大举南下，加拿大就更加老龄化，需要进口更多的人口。

吸引外资来加拿大投资毕竟是件好事，最重要的是银行不能给外资贷款，因为那其实等于用自己的钱制造自己的泡沫。

大家好， 现在SCARBOUGH 议员Jim karygiannis， 正在收集民意，向政府提出对非多伦多居民购房证税，这是他的网站：http://www.karygiannismp.com，请大家去那里投票，支持。 大家最好组织起来，向温哥华那样，向政府诉说。 这是一个好平台，望大家建立联系，保持联系，一起向政府反映

哈哈，少来，😡下回选举谁收外国人税我投谁，哪个党加的多，我投谁，加死那帮投资，摸鱼的才好。。。

真正的炒家是地产经纪，取消地产经纪，自然回归市场。经济费是造成房价上涨的主要原因。

Hi Jim, I am super happy to hear you to started by asking his own Scarborough-Agincourt constituents whether Toronto should tax foreign buyers of its homes, I am live in North York, I am very strongly to agree with you. I am unlucky there is nobody can started by asking in our place whether Toronto should tax foreign buyers of its homes, so I hope you can ask me . There is some my idea to support your asking: 1. Money to buy house Our money to buy house, it is almost half our salary after tax, if we want save these half salary, it is not easy, you know everything is expensive not only the high inflation but also the weaker Canada dollar. Another half our salary for government, which used in all roads in building, /maintenance, hospital, school, military, salary of all government staff and so on. If there are not our half salary, our government should be closed. The meantime, those foreign buyers, he buys house, suppose his money is clear, not only there is no any dollar used in all roads in building, maintenance, hospital, school, military, salary of all government stall and so on, but also they push the price of house higher and higher, affected big trouble in all road, hospital and so on because government need more money to investment in these fields, but our government never receive a foreigner half of his salary. We are not easy to get increase minimum salary at some cents for some years, to compare with the higher and higher the price house and the rent of house, it is means not only nothing, but also it is negative income, so how we live here? Therefore, Toronto must tax foreign buyers of its home, max is 50 %, it is equally to our tax. 2. The responsibility of our government First of all, I am surprised to hear Toronto Mayer John, said: welcome foreign buyers, it is free tax. These words are from our Mayer, Mr. John? The most important responsibility of government is for our people live in our place, for their basically living expensive, keep well or keep going, never keep worse. Their responsibility is for a foreigner. This is a commonsense, these or those foreign buyers, to push the price of house to the higher and higher, one day our local people should rent their house to live, looks like we local people lives in a foreign country, is it a hope of our Mayer? Mr. Jim, thanks for your great job to help your local people, this is great thing, we will always think of you when we have big trouble in living on Toronto. Thanks again.

House is for people to live, no for people to invest and make profit. From this point of view, the tax for non-resident should be levy at least 30% and more. People do not want to see the bubble keep blowing, and it hurts, as we will have to pay more property tax, and less opportunity for our kids afford to buy and enjoy the life.

没有该不该，只有想不想。

这里面炒房的人天天说外资好，其实大部分是中资吧。我一直不太明白，大家都知道这几年中国的钱是印出来的，既然是印出来的，那加拿大为了刺激经济也可以印钱，每个人每月发$3000块，那经济立马可以高速发展，也比把房产卖给外国人强啊。

这里的有识之士所言极是。税务居民辛苦交税，从而保障着这里的医疗、教育、政府、国防安全, 等等...... 外国庞大的炒房资金的目的是炒高房价，从而盘剥盈利。当房价暴涨起来的时候，看看中国，有多少人还能安居乐业，去做需要时间、精力、耐心的研究、科学，又有多少企业能安心发展，百花齐放，从而推动社会的发展？ 合理抑制房产投机行为是为了维护稳定的社会发展的需要。不是谁住土地房或公寓的问题，不是均贫富或不劳而获的问题，而是是否有利于房屋的可负担性的问题。如果疯狂的投机行为真正有利于社会的发展，文中干嘛提及那么多限制炒房的国家和地区，他们都是傻子，不想赚钱？ 记得网上的一个故事， 大意如下：一位非常有钱的女士嫁给美国最有钱的财阀的继承人之一，但是依旧关心经济的健康发展。有记者采访她，问及， “您已经没有任何经济后顾之忧，为何还要关心、推动经济的健康发展？” 对方回答说，经济不健康，大家都不会过的愉快。中国话说：覆巢之下安有完卵。 这里是Jim Karygiannis 关于是否开征外国人买房附加税的网上调查链接。 http://www.karygiannis.net/ (然后选择： Have Your Say – Should the City of Toronto levy an extra tax for non-Canadian resident purchases of residential properties?） 或者直接点击： http://karygiannis.net/wp/local-engagement-page/ 两者都可以选择转换成中文

没有办法，中国等第三世界国家崛起加拿大发展无力了，原来的经济规律不好使了，低利率多少年了也没有起到大作用，不敢减下来。高房价政府还分得一大杯羹，政府即使想关心自己的臣民，但苦于没招，不敢减息，可以尝试收税来打压一下投机，不作为只会快速沦落到二流国家去

加拿大是加拿大人的，对于外房税不仅要加，而且越高越好，让那些影响我们安居乐业的外国炒房者、那些唯利是图的房产经纪律师哭去吧。

房价降，经济好，大家才有钱去消费，全面经济腾飞。。。加外国人附加税加加加。。。加的更猛些吧。。。

我觉得光收买房税不够，应该做个限制，大部分房产外国人不能买，指定一部分房产只卖外国人，本国人不能买卖，外国人的房子只能在外国人中间流通，做成两个池子，让他炒去吧。。。炒的越高，政府每年收的地税越多。再把银行贷款限制一下，只能贷给本国人。这样他要炒随便炒。

这种决定，应该跳过有利益冲突的政府，由人们直接决定，来个省民公决，决定是否对外国人收税。民主国家，最终利益要归于大多数人。

为了小年轻住独立屋，政府如果傻到拒绝外来资金，没救了。

who will oppose an Act of Toronto should tax foreign buyers of its homes: 1. All salesperson of house, including broker, manager, Mr. Larry Cerqua, represented TREB and Mr. Ray Ferris, represented OREA. There are more benefits great group get huge money in our worse economic of Canada. Their salespersons always increase every month, till now all salesperson are around 150000, now almost everyone want pass these exams to get more money, the cost of the exam about $10k, the registration charges about $2 k a year. So Mr. Larry and Mr. Ray, how many money you can go it for this ?We all, Toronto people, except them, our life are going down or worse, we must save money with any dollar, but their life are more bright and fresh with their luxury cars, lives in big, huge houses. They keep their life like this always forever, they want our life keep worse. What they think it is the price of house always going up, get more commission, as same time, when we save money with any dollar, never catch up with the more than 10% or 20% of the price of the house anural, 10%, 20 %, it is means $100000- $ 300000 a year, if we will get these money, our salary almost double with them because we must pay tax , equal half of our salary for all staff of our government and all construction and maintenance of Toronto for, all road, hospital, school, police offices, Fire station and so on. For all, how we can save the extra $100000-$300000 every year? Only for Lottery we have chance !!! Therefore, they will oppose any Act of Toronto should tax foreign buyers of its homes for the above reasons. And they will threaten our government if we have any Act of Toronto should tax foreign buyers of its homes, our economic will be worse and worse. But they never will say it is benefits for our Toronto people, who will buy someplace to live, with they save money all life from one dollar to another one dollar after tax. 2. All owner of house, maybe they will keep quiet. Of course, they have own house, always think this price everyday going up, up and up. But they maybe neglect the tax of the house simultaneously going up, up and up, if the owner, he has only house, these up and down, did you care on not, but you pay more tax ever year, it is real situation, your life should be going down, maybe one day the price of house is back to your original price, how do you think about it?

加拿大是加拿大人的

华人在地产市场或许能呼风唤雨，但在其他方面特别是政治上只有天知道了，真到局面失控时，别说是华人jj华人地产律师，就是华人议员都没辙。

自由党拿房价忽悠中国人内掐，然后大量引入中东难民开动生育机器，把中国人变成阴扭特人！没脑子的跟着叫好，自由党连任就靠这些选民啦

应该好好总结一下经验教训，回头找那些这十几年来一直忽悠你们别买房子的LOSER朋友算账

The government can do a lot of things to control the house price but high house price is the only thing works for the government now High price means the government can get more tax. If the house price goes down, construction industry will goes down too. Right now, only construction industry is working well. All other industries or export are down.

对此作者不感冒

加税是对的，必须加，而且要高如60%起。但也有例外如在北极投资可以不加，在一些少人的小镇可以不加，买condo可以不加。

最近温哥华的房价是不是降下来了？之前的炒家是不是主要为华人而且是中国大陆的华人？ 人家的政策错了吗？效果不大和不好吗？ 对人民大众负责任的政府就应该沉重打击严重扰乱社会秩序、为害大众的各种行为。 买房的主要目的不是为了居住而是为了炒房，这不该允许。

中国人去支持针对中国人的税，脑袋被驴踢了。到头来自讨苦吃。

使劲加，加到每个人都能买得起4000尺的大house为止，最好能大学一毕业就能买得起富豪山庄的大房子，这样民主就胜利了。