1. 无忧资讯 /
  2. 本地 /
  3. 安省专家痛斥:留学移民是噱头! /

安省专家痛斥:留学移民是噱头!大批学生痛苦挣扎!

近日,安省伦敦的一位移民专家表示,各大留学中介在“推销”时所说的工作和移民,很多时候无法实现,但学生们有可能为此已经押上了一切。

图源:lfpress

Earl Blaney是一位有执照的移民顾问,他说这种做法诱使一些国际学生来到加拿大,以为他们会获得永久居留权和工作,然后才知道他们缺乏成功所需的基本技能。

Blaney表示:“这不是关于教育的事情,这是关于移民的问题。对于Fanshawe College招收国际学生的人来说,他们在海外的代理人就是这样推销的。”

他补充说这种做法也发生在安大略的其他学院。

图源:lfpress

Blaney说,他对来自一些国家(如菲律宾)的国际招生不用提供英语能力证明表示担忧。

“招生时,Fanshawe把工作和公民身份展现给学生,我担心的是这两者都没有。没有数据表明Fanshawe正在成功地为学生实现这两者。”

Blaney说,他与许多国际学生打交道,他的大多数客户是菲律宾人。虽然英语是这个东南亚国家的两种官方语言之一,但他说语言能力“在那里并不统一。”

他说:“我每天都会看到来我办公室的学生,他们绝对是在痛苦中挣扎。他们压力很大,并意识到在加拿大学习将更加困难,甚至不可能。”

“整个家庭的财富已经被抵押在这个推销上了。我认为这是值得讨论的。”

图源:immigrationshop

Fanshawe对此回应说,所有来自官方语言不是英语的国家申请Fanshawe的学生必须通过英语能力测试,或提供高中英语成绩达到要求的证明。

该学院说,国际学生来自119个国家,毕业生总就业率为83.1%。Fanshawe没有提供只针对国际学生的就业率。

Fanshawe在一份书面声明中说:“至关重要的是,学生有足够的书面和口头英语知识,适合他们所申请的项目。英语是第二语言的申请人必须在申请程序中提交其英语能力的证据。”

今年秋季,Fanshawe学院的国际招生人数激增了26%,有4200名学生来自印度、尼泊尔、尼日利亚、中国、哥伦比亚、韩国和越南等地。

国际学生院长Wendy Curtis上个月说,新生是“支持劳动力市场”的一种方式。

“我们的国内学生人口已经缩减。根据人口统计学,预计几年后会恢复到较高的水平。这是我们比历史上接受更多国际学生的一个关键原因。我们有能力做到这一点。”

图源:uvic

根据学习许可,国际学生可以来加拿大学习并申请工作许可,并可能有机会得到永久居留权。

Curtis说:“他们是未来的公民和雇员。”

但Blaney说,“在最大程度上,我们的系统只能吸收这些国际学生的30%。”

他说:“绝大部分的扩招是在社区学院层面上进行的。它是可以负担得起的。”

他说,国际学生在社区学院每年的平均学费约为$16,000元,而在加拿大大学,一年的学费可能是这个数字的两到三倍。

图源:georgebrown

最近的一份报告说:“对许多人来说,加拿大的教育可能不会产生预期的投资回报。”

根据该报告,加拿大是国际学生的第三大目的地,仅次于美国和澳大利亚。他们占所有在加拿大高等教育机构就读的学生的20%。

许多国际学生可能“不了解应对加拿大的高生活成本、劳动力市场或复杂的工作许可制度的挑战。”

“加拿大需要受过大学教育的学生来解决整个经济中的劳动力短缺问题。但是,一些参加短周期课程的学生,进入劳动力市场和获得永久居留权将更艰难,而一些人可能根本没有机会。”

图源:rapidmigration

安省各学院拒绝发表评论,有学校在一封电子邮件中说:“我们与每个学院的个别运作无关。”

现如今,“留学移民一条龙”仿佛已经变成了中介的“标语”,甚至有人用“留学可以结识更多富二代,嫁个好归宿”为噱头为招生造势。

所以还是希望广大留学生在挑选学校的时候,多了解、多调查,要有判断能力,不能完全相信一些话术。

来源链接:
  • https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/fanshawes-sales-pitch-to-international-students-missing-the-mark-consultant

网友评论

网友评论仅供其表达个人看法,并不表明 51.CA 立场。
中介黑心!
回复
这种学院能教啥,加拿大需要啥,层次低的工作。所以从上到下(政府到学校),这种大规模移民留学就是捞钱而已
回复
The Liberals are bringing in 1.3 million new immigrants into this country in under 3 years. This is not about 'race for global talent' they are trying to keep the housing market propped up and wages depressed for their corporate overlords by giving PRs away to Subway supervisors. If you don't get into the housing market before all these people do, you are going to be SOL for ever being able to own a home in this country. This is from the Chief economists at two of Canada's major banks: High levels of immigration and not enough housing has created a supply crisis in Canada: Chief Economist at Scotiabank Canadian wage growth lagging U.S. due to immigration levels: CIBC For the love of all that is holy bringing in 1.3 million new immigrants into this country in under 3 years is not sustainable when we have a housing and rental crisis. That's the population of Calgary, we are not creating new cities in this country to be able to house these people. Immigration Canada does not have the resourcing to properly vet and process 1.3 million people. People think we are getting only high skilled workers but that is the furthest from the truth. There is rampant immigration fraud going, especially in the International Student Program. This puts heavy downward pressure on low end wages that low income Canadians are counting on. Not to mention upward pressure on an already unaffordable housing market. We should bring our immigration numbers into line with what Joe Biden is doing in the US. The US will be taking in 500K new immigrants this year, but they have 10x our population. Adjusted for Canada's population we should then be taking in 50K this year not 430K. It's not like the US economy is collapsing due to these numbers, like some would make you believe would happen here if we did that. BTW I would love to see the reaction of Americans if Biden got on camera and announced he was going to increase immigration numbers to bring in 10.3 million immigrants into the country in under 3 years (as adjusted to Canada's policy). Also the Liberals immigration program is like a vote kick back scheme for them to lock in future voters. They purposely turn a blind eye to the rampant immigration fraud that is going on with immigration programs like in the International Student Program. They then let the students get to backdoor their way into PR (making immigrants doing things the legit way scratch their heads as to how someone who works as a supervisor at a Subway got PR before them), and then to citizenship. These cheats will be forever grateful to the Liberals for allowing this and vote accordingly. There are literally international students driving around with decals on their car blessing Trudeau for allowing them to come here: Just look at Bramptons voting pattern from the last election where a lot of these 2yr Sheridan college diploma students settled: table placeholder There is so much fraud going it's not even funny: Article The overwhelming majority of Chinese students here are enrolled at Canadian universities (83 per cent). The vast majority of Indian students, meanwhile, are registered at colleges (73 per cent). Students and recruitment businesses interviewed by The Globe say this is because most Indian students want to come to Canada to live rather than learn, and registering in a college program offers a cheaper and faster path to settling here (after landing in Canada on a student visa, they can get a postgraduate work permit and start logging the employment hours necessary to apply for permanent residency and, down the road, Canadian citizenship). Article: A recent StatsCan analysis could not find indications that 30.5 per cent of people in the country on post-secondary study permits in 2015 were signed up that year at a Canadian college or university. Immigration Department report that revealed 25 per cent of would-be foreign students in Canada in 2018 were likely not complying with the conditions of their visa Compared to Britain, the U.S. and Australia, Canada is known for having a poor record of tracking study-visa holders once they’re in the country. Toronto Star reported in November that many would-be international students are routinely fail to pursue their studies, instead looking for work and applying for permanent residency. The Globe and Mail also reported last month that many trucking companies, primarily in Surrey, are taking large illegal cash payments from foreign students in exchange for truck-driver jobs that might help them qualify for permanent residency. Immigration department officials have acknowledged a tenth of all study-visa applications are fraudulent, often because they use faked acceptance letters from Canadian institutions. "Some work full-time in contravention of the terms of their study permit, which limits them to working no more than 20 hours a week when school is in session, plus full-time during scheduled school vacations." Some, Hyman said, obtain work "off the books for cash." Canada’s more than 650 institutes of higher education are allowed to follow the honour system in informing authorities about study-visa infractions. And even though Canadian schools have been required since 2016 to report on their total international-student enrolment, 68 schools failed to do even that last year . Article: Some Indo-Canadian business owners, Purewal said, collude with the agents to charge Indian students $20,000 to $50,000 for a false labour-market assessment, which claims a foreign national is needed for a job because Canadians cannot be found. Vancouver immigration lawyer Sam Hyman says there is a “rampant” underground economy devoted to creating false labour-market assessments for international students in Canada. Article Immigration consultants often arrange the illicit deals, which frequently result in Canadian business owners being paid to fabricate non-existent jobs. The employers, for their part, devise fraudulent pay stubs so the foreign nationals can "prove" to immigration officials they have needed skills to go to the front of the queue to become a permanent resident of Canada. In one redacted letter obtained under an access to information request, a Canadian provided details about how her colleague was "getting her cheques and returning cash money to her employer just to show fake employment." "My research uncovers allegations of fake jobs, examples of fake jobs, and complaints by visa officers about fake jobs. It shows that some people who can’t qualify under our rules will pay big money to get their visa illicitly." "I get this on a regular basis. I’m offered fees from $10,000 to $50,000, plus they will pay their own salaries. So I could bring employees here and have them work for free" said the businessman, who asked to not be identified. Many job descriptions, which are either bogus or exaggerated to make them seem more "skilled" The 2010 evaluation of Canada’s skilled worker program concluded: "Fraud is commonly associated with job offers from non-existent employers, fictitious positions incompatible with the type of business operations, offers of convenience from friends or family members, and genuine offers with inflated job descriptions."
回复
学院教的都是技术和执照,电工,修车,木工,厨师,金融理财,牙医,护士等等,这些是加拿大比较容易找工作的,工资也不低,大学反而更难找合适工作。
回复
回复 小胖掌厨:工资不低是因为有行会把持,没有竞争。这些工作放在国内,根本不需要那么多钱。加拿大应该发展高端行业,去世界挣钱,而不是内卷。
回复
展开 3 条回复
留学可以结识红二代, 一颗红心献给党, 指导加拿大如何搞建设, 对加拿大教育科技房地产指手画脚, 传播中国大陆经验, 搞全球命运共同体, 嘿呦嘿呦, 下面就是泰坦尼克号。
回复
有良心的移民留学中介了
回复
实诚人啊。还有免费医疗,免费教育,福利。。。
回复
早就是这样。其实,第一代移民就是这样,不过是现在什么都变差了,所以变得更明显。
回复
x
x